Pineapple

The buff it gives is the weakest food tier, so chewing one is close to wasting it. Fruit feeds into Ambrosia through shimmer, and that sits at the top of the food list, so the sensible habit is a chest that collects fruit until you have the whole set.

Shaking rich mahogany trees in the jungle. That puts it in the category of things you collect while doing something else, since the chance per tree is low and no specific tree is better than another. Shake everything you pass while clearing jungle wood and you will have them without ever making a trip for it.

The tooltip is a jab at pineapple on pizza, which is the most reliable way to start an argument about food on the internet.